
4 minute read
Pups are sentient beings with their own distinct emotions, right? Recent research suggests that across Canada, most households think of their pups as true members of the family. Even globally, the general sentiment towards pets is changing from being considered“things” to being widely considered as “living beings”. But, is this shift in perspective mostly helpful or harmful? And, what effect can it have on your pup’s well being?
Simply put, to personify your pup means to give human-like qualities, emotions, and behaviors to your dog. We see so many examples of this in popular culture that we almost don’t even notice it. In pop culture, some of the most well known examples are Disney movies. The adorable characteristics given to pups on screen such as the characters Lady and the Tramp makes them seem as though they operate with the same psyche and physicality as real people! If we look back to our history over thousands of years, humans have long been giving these types of personified roles to dogs ranging from guardians, guides, and even deities.
Technically speaking, a psychologist would refer to this tendency as anthropomorphism which is similarly defined as attributing human characteristics and emotions to non-human entities such as pets. In today’s day and age, it’s incredibly common for a household to create a persona (sometimes an incredibly elaborate one!) for their pup. The idea that pups have human-like personalities is perpetuated widely across popular culture, in the media, in our everyday expressions and some even refer to their pets as their “children”. These days, you’ll see pups with their own social media following, health insurance, designer accessories, and even their own meal delivery services. In colloquial language, no one still refers to their pup as an “it”. We use human pronouns to describe our little buddies, and the way people express themselves through language has a ripple effect on the way people perceive them. Afterall, for humans, the evolutionary purpose of personifying supernatural forces and other animals around us has served to help humans create mental models of the world in order to better understand it and ultimately, to dominate it.
So, is it a good thing or a bad thing that we tend to humanize our pups?
First, there’s the bad. Don’t assume that your pup’s physical or mental and emotional needs are the same as yours. Looking at your pup’s behaviour through a human lens can set them up to fail as a result of unrealistic expectations. Humans reliably under or overestimate the intelligence and capability of their pets (Leach et. al., 2023). Examples of this may include when a pup parent expects a pup to “know better,” “feel guilty,” “be patient”, or if a pup parent expects them to suppress or not express their natural instincts. Pup parents sometimes have the urge to dress their pups in clothes or give them human food, of which both can be risks to a pup’s health and well being. Research also brings to light the dangers of thinking as if our pets are acting in a human-like manner when we attempt to train them. This can lead us to misinterpret their behaviour and respond inappropriately, such as with harsh punishment. It’s becoming more widely accepted that dogs don’t actually experience spite, guilt or a myriad of other human-like emotions, and therefore, these emotions should not be attributed as the cause of their behaviour. A common misconception is when pup owners mistakenly think that they would alleviate their pup’s “loneliness” by getting them another pup as a companion, when just as often as not, another pup personality added to the mix isn’t actually an ideal solution for filling the void of missing their humans when they’re at work or not at home during the day.
Personifying your pup or thinking about them as your child isn’t all negative. It actually does help to strengthen the bond across species and promotes empathetic feelings, not just towards your pet, but towards all beings in general too. It has been shown that a large part of the benefits that pup parents experience in terms of companionship and associated mental health benefits are attributed to the fact that humans do engage in anthropomorphism (Hiestand et al., 2022).
Research shows that more empathic owners reported to have fewer problems with their dogs (Szantho et al., 2017). This type of empathy can encourage pup parents to think more openly about getting their pup’s consent for physical affection and other activities. Our pups have their own way of communicating and this opens up the possibility that training can be bidirectional between a pup and their parents. Overall, being aware of this innately human tendency to personify the world, especially our pups and other animals, helps us delve deeper into how we might improve as a pup parent for our little buddies.